Crossword puzzles are excellent tools for expanding one’s problem-solving skills and vocabulary, but the “tricks” some editors use to complete the puzzle can lead the unknowing, who look at crossword puzzles as authoritative sources for information, to believe that these tricks represent correct spelling.
This particular puzzle contained two instances of letters being spelled as words: 26 Across – Pluralizing letter, and 34 Down – Sweater alternative to crew or turtle. 26 Across is the least offensive of these because the clue referred to a letter, a singular item that should require only one space, but the three blank spaces for the answer made it apparent that the editor wanted to spell the letter phonetically, as if it was a word. I think this particular example is less problematic than 34 Down because I doubt that people will start spelling the letter S as though it was a word.
Alphabetic letters are basic symbols that represent particular sounds. The English language uses those symbols in sequences to spell words that are composed of multiple sounds. Since letters represent sounds, it doesn’t make sense for letters to be spelled as though they were words. Doing so would have us speaking words by stating the names of the letter they are spelled with, so the simple, single-syllable word ‘dog‘ would be pronounced ‘dee-oh-jee,’ or as we teach children how to pronounce words in grammar school, ‘duh-ahh-ghu.’
34 Down, where the answer the editor wanted was ‘vee,’ as in V-neck T-shirt, is more problematic because of the growing number of people who don’t seem to know that a V-neckline was so named because it resembles the letter V, not because its proper name is Vee. Similarly, people often think that T-shirt is spelled ‘tee shirt.‘ Are crossword puzzles to blame for this deteroration? No. I believe that the reason people spell letters as words is due to a problem with orally-dependent languages — people tend to repeat what they hear and spell it phonetically without understanding the context or source for words and names, or bothering to use a dictionary before writing what they hear.
A common set of letters to be spelled as a word, often in crossword puzzles, is M.C., spelled as ‘emcee.’ While I like to believe that crossword puzzle editors know that the letters M.C. are initials representing the term, ‘Master of Ceremonies,’ I am not convinced that the average person knows it. We are inherently lazy people, in that we like to carry-out tasks with the greatest amount of efficiency, which is why we shorten frequently used terms to their initials (acronyms), and use contractions, like ‘I’m’ to save a syllable’s time and breath, rather than say ‘I am.’ If people knew that ‘M.C.‘ was a two-letter acronym, and not a word, I think they would rather write the two letters, than spell-out the five-letter “word” ‘emcee.’
I don’t have a solution to suggest for this problem. Given the tendency for people to rely solely on oral transmission of the language, part of me wants to suggest that crossword puzzle editors refrain from creative puzzle-making, but the other part of me appreciates creativity and enjoys such tricks in word games.